I love the rearrangement I did moving the comfy couches into the TV room. It has created an awesome, cozy space for my friends and family to hang out in. (I still want to add some color to the walls and some curtains, but that's in the works).
Since the furniture swap, I have felt a bit concerned for my "formal living room." It used to have my comfy couches and so it was the place where both my small groups gathered weekly. But as a "formal living room," it really doesn't get used any more. The kids play in it every now and then but the grownups never go in there and it feels like a wasted space. That's really a shame, because it's a great, big room. One of my friends was trying to sell her grand piano and that got me really inspired to buy a piano for that room and make it a friendly music/reading space. I really need you to come to my house and see this for yourself, but since you probably can't do that, hopefully you can help me from just pictures.
I really like the window-wall...the couch between the end tables and plants looks nice to me (still needs window treatments, but again, that's another work in progress).
This corner I don't love. This nook, between the two grand columns, is where I can see a grand or mini-grand piano really completing the room. The round end would fit nicely between the columns and the keyboard end would face the rest of the room. (And I do play at a basic level and would like to practice and improve as well as teach my kids). Unfortunately I can't afford that kind of piano.
Then another friend offered me a low price on an upright piano. It sounded like a great idea but then I considered the space where I had envisioned my piano. While I think a grand or baby-grand would look great in this nook, I think an upright would see odd here because of the space behind the columns. Don't you think an upright needs to be against a wall? Or is there some way I could decorate the space behind it so that it didn't seem odd?

Another option is to completely rearrange the room and put the upright in this corner. But that would mean uprooting my happy red couch/table/plant combo. If you look back up at the pic of my TV room, I could also put the upright in place of the china cabinet. The china cabinet really doesn't belong there but when I turned my formal dining room into a game room, it had to go somewhere else and that's the only place. If I replace it, it will have to be sold and I'm not sure if that's the right thing to do since I still have the matching table and chairs (I'd be fine getting rid of it, but I would have guilt at not keeping the set together...they were my moms).

My final option is to pass on the piano for now...start saving for a used mini-grand...and use that money for paint and curtains. This would not solve my "formal living room" problem, but it might be the smarted move. What do you think? Why is this so hard and complicated for me? I love the idea of decorating but I hate the reality.
In case I totally confused you with too much information, here are the questions/options:
1. Do you think an upright needs to be against a wall? Or is there some way I could decorate the space behind it so that it didn't seem odd? Basically, should an upright piano go between those columns?
2. Should I rearrange the room so that the piano can go in that corner and move the red couch/table/plants somewhere else?
3. Should I get rid of the china cabinet, even though it matches the table and chairs, and put the upright piano in it's place?
4. Should I hold off on the piano idea and spend my $ on paint and curtains for now?